Moti Tesgera
English 4
Artist as a scapegoat
Over time there has been a line between morals and ethics. These things have been a principle and have been followed and when they are not followed or broken there are always consequences. In "The Shape of things" there is a reference of ancient biblical history. This is by sin consuming Eve and making her eat the apple and then making Adam eat the apple. A similar thing happened in "The Shape of things" were Evelyn slept with Adam and they both cheated on their girlfriend or fiancee.
If I had to chose one person out of these four to pick as the most unethical would be Evelyn. I would chose her because the moment they introduced her into the play she was already vandalizing and breaking some rule. Just like how in the bible eve did not want to listen to Adam and she wanted to eat the apple, Evelyn did not want to leave the museum and she wanted to spray paint the statue. She is the clear cut person who is the most unethical.
Another person that would be considered unethical is Adam. I would say Adam because he slept with Jenny. But after he slept with her he lied to Evelyn and said all they did was kiss. Jenny could also be another person who is unethical. This is because she sleeps with Adam. But, The difference between Adam and Jenny is that Jenny is engaged to Philip.
At the end the person who is the most unethical would be Evelyn. I chose her because she is the one that is made to look like the villain in the play. All the way from the beginning the play writer makes her seem like the villain. He does this buy making her break several rules in the first scene when they were in the museum. He makes her seem this way from the beginning to paint a picture in our heads so that we will allways think that Evelyn is the villain and Adam is not. I personally chose Evelyn because if it werent for her actions adam would have never done what he did.
At the end the person who is the most unethical would be Evelyn. I chose her because she is the one that is made to look like the villain in the play. All the way from the beginning the play writer makes her seem like the villain. He does this buy making her break several rules in the first scene when they were in the museum. He makes her seem this way from the beginning to paint a picture in our heads so that we will allways think that Evelyn is the villain and Adam is not. I personally chose Evelyn because if it werent for her actions adam would have never done what he did.
I agree with you when you say Adam and Jenny are morally incorrect, and I also agree that the most unethical character in the play was Evelyn because her actions were cruel and inhuman.
ReplyDeleteI also agree and also think that Evelyn is being made to be the villain
ReplyDeleteI like your reference to the Bible story, but can you clarify how Eve "made" Adam eat the apple? I think this carries over into the whole play. Who is ultimately responsible for Adam? In exchange for pleasure, he does whatever she says. He doesn't bother to get to know her--if he'd actually asked real questions and asked to meet her parents, etc., the game would have been up.
ReplyDeleteThe irony in all of this is Eve didn't try to get Adam to do drugs or rob a bank or quit school. She altered him to fit society's idea of beauty. The "damage" she did wasn't damage at all, unless you count the hurt feelings. But all relationships involve hurt feelings at some point.
But it is troubling that Eve could be so detached from hurting Adam so badly because she wanted to make great art and was uncompromising in trying to make it (not interested in the "Ethic of Caring").
Any way, I hope we can agree Labute's play is great art--it is uncomfortable, makes us think, and brings to light something that beneath the surface. I think the strong female character is an added bonus. I suspect if Eve was a guy and Adam was a girl, we'd take less issue with the manipulation that went on.
I agree, Eve took things way too far
ReplyDeleteIn some way I agree, Evelyn did do wrong by playing with Adam's feelings, but she made him better, she made him more confident. Although his feelings were hurt, he did benefit from the whole situation, he a whole other person because of her. He went from being unnoticed, to being noticed by people because of his appearance.
ReplyDelete